making homework work
This guide aims to highlight some issues, challenges and good practice related to homework that we have identified – and help you decide how homework works best for you and your setting. It is aimed at all those working within out-of-school-hours learning.
This is available in English and Welsh.
Making
homework
work
There is renewed interest in the value of homework, and
the role that it plays in school life and outside school hours.
This guide aims to highlight some issues, challenges and
good practice related to homework that we have identified
– and help you decide how homework works best for you
and your setting. It is aimed at all those working within
out-of-school-hours learning.
The guide contains a wide range of case studies showing
innovative and effective approaches to homework. If you
would like your experiences of homework to appear on
our website or in future publications, please email us at
info.cardiff@continyou.org.uk telling us what you are
involved in.
‘Any learning activity that pupils are
asked to do outside of normal lesson time can
be regarded as homework.’
The quotes highlighted like this are taken
from Homework in primary and secondary schools –
a study by Estyn (2004) of homework in schools
in Wales. To view and download the report,
visit the Estyn website at www.estyn.gov.uk.
2
Background
Because of its less than voluntary nature, homework is not
always seen as part of out-of-school-hours learning (oshl).
However, with its origins as ‘prep’ back in the public school
system, it may be the most extensive, and oldest, form of
school-focused out-of-school-hours learning.
Over the years homework has become an
apparently essential ingredient of secondary
schooling, despite not being a statutory
requirement; in some form, homework is
now also firmly rooted in most primary
schools.
Although it is generally agreed among
education professionals, parents, governors and
politicians that constructive homework can be a ‘good
thing’, or at least a necessity, there are those with either a very
rigid or very easy-going approach to homework at both an
institutional and individual level.
A new debate at last?
There has been no academic study to prove and assess the real
value of homework. The logic behind setting homework seems
to have developed from a professional belief that constructive
learning at home is an essential element in developing the
lifelong learner.
In secondary schools especially, it is generally seen as necessary
to cover the demands of the national curriculum, and to build
children’s levels of attainment. Add to that custom and
practice, and expectations of a ‘good school’, and we end
up with tight homework timetables and school homework
policies, which generate pressures for the pupil, teacher and
family, and result in outcomes of varying quality.
The opposite extreme is championed by the American
academic Alfie Kohn in his new book The homework myth: why
our children get too much of a bad thing (2006). In this he
attempts to explode the myth, and suggests that, at least for
younger children, homework should not intrude on their life
out of school at all – in fact, it should not exist at all.
His argument appears to be sparking a debate here in Britain,
at least in the press. This will be welcome if we eventually
emerge with a genuine understanding of what the purpose of
homework is, what it can achieve, how it sits comfortably with
an out-of-school life, and some useful signposting through the
issues that it raises. In the meantime, it is largely up to schools
to find their own way.
The Welsh Assembly Government
Unlike their England counterparts, where advisory homework
hours at each key stage have been set by the government,
the Welsh Assembly Government (WAG) has not become
very embroiled in the homework debate – emphasising that
homework is not a statutory requirement and that it is the
responsibility of the headteacher and governors of each
school to decide homework policy, including the amount of
homework set.
The WAG recognises the important contribution that
homework makes to pupils’ progress at school, and in helping
them to achieve high standards, through:
‘Homework
partnerships with parents, carers and
pupils can extend high quality learning
experiences beyond the school day.’
3
• consolidating work done in lessons
• encouraging pupils to extend and develop independent
learning skills
• allowing individuals to work at a pace that is appropriate
to their abilities.
Since 1998, all schools have been required to have a
written home–school agreement explaining the respective
responsibilities of schools and parents in raising standards;
homework usually forms part of this agreement.
The quantity issue
Views among education professionals, parents
and children vary greatly as to how much
homework should be set. Indeed, it is
almost impossible to quantify homework as
children work at different paces, in different
environments, and with different degrees of
commitment.
Work which involves ‘finishing off’ a class task is likely to
be more onerous for the slower worker, and less challenging
for the more able. Differentiated homework for a mixed-ability
class of 30 children can become an administrative and
assessment nightmare.
In particular, conflict with the wide range of other school and
non-school-based social and learning opportunities available to
young people today can create unnecessary stresses when
homework is inflexibly set and is over-burdensome.
We should not lose sight either of the pressures on those
children who carry the burden of caring responsibilities at
home – whether for siblings, parents or other relatives – or on
those who have work commitments after school.
The quality issue
Almost all secondary and some primary schools have a
homework policy, a homework timetable, and a form of
homework diary for each pupil. However, setting and
completing homework are not without their
challenges. Homework can become an
emotive subject, with teachers, parents,
governors and elected representatives
(as well of course as the young people
themselves) holding strong and varying views
on its quantity, content, style, purpose,
effectiveness and equality of opportunity. This can
mean that ‘letting sleeping dogs lie’ can be a more
attractive option than exploring moves away
from the traditional approach to homework.
It is clear that, where homework tasks and
expectations are ill-considered, or practised
slavishly rather than logically, pupils do not
buy in to the idea – meaning that the whole
concept is counter-productive and unlikely to
induce a love of learning or a sense of personal
[Regarding other activities a
young person might participate in outside
school hours] ‘Homework should not restrict
a child’s access to these opportunities
to develop.’
‘A great many young
people have part-time jobs that add to the
pressure on them...’
‘Homework which merely fills up
pupils’ time...is unlikely to be productive
and may prevent valuable development
that would otherwise occur through play
and other interests.’
4
responsibility for lifelong learning. At its worst,
it can simply be time wasting for both pupil and teacher, and
a source of conflict at home and at school.
However, there are a number of schools where genuine,
imaginative attempts to address such thorny issues are being
made. Some of these are new and unproven in the longer
term, but have evolved from positive thinking and, sometimes,
true partnership.
In contrast, at local authority level, while there are examples
of officers supporting individual school initiatives, it has
not been possible to find a Welsh example of an
authority-wide perspective or leadership around
homework issues. The nearest is Cardiff,
where the authority funds the learning
centres; indeed, the only example so far
unearthed of an LEA taking the lead is
from County Durham in England
(see the ‘Case studies’ section).
Parents and the home
Given that homework is largely meant to be
completed at home, in the parents’ house
and perhaps in their presence, it may be
seen as surprising that, traditionally, there
has been little consultation between schools
and parents as to how this arrangement can
be managed to best effect. All too often
parents have been expected to demonstrate
a passive acceptance of what the child brings
home, providing a bit of help where they can.
Fortunately, there is now more of a focus on the benefits for
the child, the parents and family life if parents can be involved
in supporting their child’s learning from an early age. Various
initiatives, both national and local, are now growing in range
and significance as the importance of such support is
understood and accepted. An example of one such
initiative is given in the ‘Case studies’ section.
The language issue
The growing phenomenon of children of
English-speaking families attending Welshmedium
or bilingual schools can generate some
difficulties in home–school communication – in
particular, preventing parents from supporting their
children’s home learning as much as they would like.
But some help is available (see the ‘Case studies’ section).
‘For parents of children with
special educational needs, finding out
how children learn can help to ensure that
opportunities for learning and reinforcing
are maximised at home.’
‘Schools should have strategies for
involving parents and carers actively in their
children’s learning from the early years.’
‘For very young children,
under the age of five, homework is
about linking learning that occurs within an
organised setting such as a playgroup with
learning at home and elsewhere. It helps to
promote partnership between educators
and a child’s parents or carers.’
5
Equality of opportunity
Working at home
One of the challenges surrounding
homework has always been the great
variation in home circumstances
experienced by children. Homework has
mainly been set on the assumption that there
is a dedicated room or quiet space where the child
can settle down to their studies undisturbed, and
where interested but not over-intrusive parents
can provide knowledgeable support and
encouragement.
Of course, for a significant number of
children these conditions simply do not exist.
This situation has become exacerbated by the
growth in the number of homework tasks which
will benefit from, if not rely on, PC usage. This is not a
problem for those with access to PCs at home and the skills
to use them, but can disadvantage other pupils without the
hardware or the skills.
Teachers are, of course, well aware of this, and many schools
have introduced some kind of homework facility to provide at
least physical conditions that are more conducive to personal
study than some pupils might enjoy at home.
The homework club
The homework club concept has been
developed in many schools, and in many
different forms. The clubs can take place
before school starts (perhaps as part of a
breakfast club), in the lunchtimes, after
school, evenings, or Saturday mornings –
and might or might not be associated with other
activities, such as PE or sport, cultural activities, or the
OwnZone concept.
With OwnZone, a school brings together out-of-school-hours
learning activities, homework and pastoral support, and a base
for socialising, under one coherent management system –
with pupils playing a large part in the process. (To find
out more about OwnZone, visit the ContinYou website:
www.continyou.org.uk.)
Few schools are able to offer a dedicated area, and so
classrooms, libraries, ICT suites and dining rooms are all used.
Increasingly, schools are looking at working together to provide
homework facilities within the community – for example, in
Holywell, Flintshire, where a secondary school runs a club in
the local primary school to which secondary and primary
pupils are invited. Occasionally, off-site premises are identified
through a community partnership. Some of the facilities target
children with particular needs or from particular year groups;
some are subject-based; others are open to all; some operate
on a weekly basis; others daily.
Homework clubs can be well attended – but not always by
those who might benefit most. Schools have to look at ways of
making what is on offer attractive. This can include offering
‘Issues
of equality of opportunity regarding
access to support and resources need to be
considered when planning
for pupils to work at home...’
[Regarding IT] ‘...all schools and
communities need to provide clubs or to
make other arrangements…for pupils who do
not have access to computers at home.’
‘...an increasing number of
primary and secondary schools are providing
breakfast, lunchtime or after-school clubs
to help pupils with their homework.’
6
other activities alongside the facility for homework –
for example, OwnZone – and demands some
effort in ‘marketing’, developing an identity
and name, and providing a quality facility
that exceeds expectations.
How to staff clubs is a major question –
staff need to at least replicate the support
an interested parent might provide. Some clubs
depend on volunteers (such as parents or students)
and teachers giving their own time; some have found
funding to pay adults, including teachers and support
assistants; some are taking innovative approaches to contracts
for a range of support staff to cover out-of-school activities;
and in some schools pupils act as mentors and help run clubs –
often older pupils helping younger ones.
Distance from school
For many pupils the structure of the day is dominated by the
bus service. Participation in a homework club – or any type of
out-of-school-hours learning – can be difficult if alternative
transport is not readily available. For those with longer
journeys, travelling time can make significant inroads into the
time available for homework completion and other activities
when they get home from school.
In one interesting experiment in North East England, where
the main route to school is a rural railway line, one coach in
the train was fitted with laptop computers and large tables to
facilitate study during the daily journey.
Homework – an element
in transition
Smoothing the path from primary to
secondary education is one of the priorities
of the Welsh Assembly Government, with
transition plans being in place in all schools in 2007.
For some time transition has been addressed by clusters
of schools in many ways, particularly through joint and linked
curriculum projects and transfer of data. To date homework
has not featured strongly in such programmes; however, joint
homework planning between secondary and partner primary
schools can be an important element in minimising the
academic and social ‘culture shock’ of transfer.
One such scheme was developed under the ContinYou Cymru
Symud Ymlaen project by Holyhead High School in Anglesey
and four nearby primary schools, based on science, maths,
and literacy through drama. Pupils ‘opted in’ for two sessions
per week throughout Year 6 and into Year 7, which included
homework support.
The Symud Ymlaen resource is available from the ContinYou
website at www.continyou.org.uk.
Acknowledgements
This homework guide was written by Brian Hubble and
Pam Boyd on behalf of ContinYou Cymru. It was edited
by Louise Reilly and designed by Paul Mepham.
Translated by Dyfrig Selway
Published by ContinYou Cymru
ContinYou Cymru, Anchor Court, First Floor,
Keen Road, Cardiff CF24 5JW
Tel: 029 2047 8929 Fax: 029 2047 8930
Email: info.cardiff@continyou.org.uk
Website: www.continyou.org.uk
Registered charity number 1097596
‘Transition projects between Year 6
and Year 7 can help develop homework
and learning partnerships.’
‘Many pupils in rural areas of
Wales, and those attending some Welshmedium
and denominational schools,
often have long journeys to and
from school.’
Dysgu tu allan i oriau ysgol
Out of school hours learning
7
Case studies
A school bites the bullet
– Own Work in Cardiff
High
Cardiff High School has
developed an original
approach to homework
alongside, and associated
with, the development of
a ‘thinking skills’ approach
to learning, aided by
General Teaching Council
for Wales funding.
At an early stage in
consultations it became
clear that traditional
homework and tasks did
not sit comfortably with
the new ‘thinking skills’
approach, and that it
was seen to be a straitjacket.
However, as the majority
of the pupils’ parents had
traditional views on
education, some courage –
and a lot of consultation –
was needed before any
new approach to
homework could be
put in place.
A new homework policy
based around thinking
skills has now been
developed by staff,
with the aim of helping
children to become
resilient and independent
learners – and to enjoy
their homework
experience. Detailed
research with pupils
provided important
pointers as to how they
learnt best, and a
homework focus group of
twelve pupils helped to
identify the way forward.
The ‘Thinking for Learning’
approach to homework is
currently operating in
Years 7 and 8. Meaningless
tasks have now been
abolished, and analytical
‘Own Work’ tasks, with a
clear relevance, are agreed
with pupils beforehand –
which also helps to reduce
any potential for overload.
An Own Work timetable
is in use for a few subjects,
such as maths. However,
in geography, for example,
pupils work to a flexible
brief over a period of time
and produce their ‘report’
in a form and style of their
choice – and, where
appropriate, incorporate
their own hobbies and
special interests.
Own Work features too
in ‘lessons’ on Thinking
for Learning – where
pupils are encouraged to
develop a range of skills
and approaches, and to
discuss the significance of
the work they do at home.
There is also recognition
that there might be times
when even Own Work is
not desirable or possible.
Comprehensive but
unfussy procedures have
been devised to support
and guide teachers in the
setting and assessment of,
and in response to, Own
Work tasks. A twice-weekly
‘club’ has been established
in the Learning Support
Department for those who
do not have the necessary
facilities at home – and for
the occasional, though
declining, defaulters!
A local authority takes
the lead and a school is
flying – not Wales,
but Durham
Few, if any, education
authorities are taking the
lead on homework across
their areas. However, in
one authority in England –
Durham – the local
authority has been the
prime mover showing
what can be done.
Here, the focus on
homework was initiated
by the county’s strategy
manager for study
support, who requested
that it be included in the
Single Education Plan,
and gathered a group of
interested colleagues to
find a way forward.
An initial audit was held
with schools on the
relevant issues. A 70
per cent return on a
questionnaire showed that
many schools agreed that
homework was a thorny
issue.
This group then
approached several
schools for ‘model’
policies which they
thought were effective,
held discussions with
school staff, and gathered
together information on
parental views.
The strategy manager
joined the Learning
Beyond the Classroom
group at Framwellgate
School to look into the
provision of homework.
This group has since
developed the 747 pilot
project with Year 7, that is,
seven key skills for Year 7.
The project concentrates
all homework provision in
Year 7 towards building
key independent learning
skills in students, and is
supported by a 747 club
within their Learning
Resource Centre.
Teachers are encouraged
to spend more time
setting up interesting
and stimulating projects,
and are delighted with the
very high quality of the
work submitted by the
pupils.
The next step in the
process is to set aside time
for the pupils to develop
self-evaluation and peerevaluation
skills based on
their homework.
The local authority is now
currently planning to find
and fund three more
schools who are ready to
take an alternative look at
homework. This will then
generate more serious
dialogue with all the area’s
schools, with a focus on
parental involvement and
incorporating action
research.
Schools do seem ready to
move on, as the strategy
manager says: ‘I have had
no difficulty in persuading
colleagues of the need to
change both the culture
surrounding homework
and the focus of how it
helps children to learn;
the difficulty is finding a
route to follow which will
provide us with a lasting
“mindshift” for all
stakeholders’.
Parents and children
together – the Share
programme
The ability of a child
to tackle homework tasks
successfully and to
overcome problems they
might encounter with
their homework depends
significantly on the
parent’s ability and
confidence in providing
useful help and advice –
especially in the earlier
years. On this, the 2004
Estyn report on homework
had some positive things
to say about Share.
Share is a national (UK)
practical approach to
involving parents in their
children’s education and
to increasing their
appreciation of the vital
role they play in children’s
learning – so that
providing support for
homework becomes a
natural process.
Share can be provided
by local education
authorities or schools and
other community settings.
The parents/carers – and
other family members –
are invited to practical
sessions with trained
practitioners, using
high-quality materials
linked to the curriculum of
the Foundation Stage and
at Key Stages 1 to 3.
Some of the materials are
available in languages
other than English.
The programme supports
parents to develop their
8
own skills too (in IT, for
example), even leading
to Open College Network
accreditation – or less
formally, in helping them
to feel more involved and
in partnership with the
school.
Share has been developed
by ContinYou. Visit
www.share.org.uk or
www.continyou.org.uk/
share to find out more.
Saesneg at home,
Cymraeg in school? –
Welsh Language Board
Support Line
Following a pilot period,
the Welsh Language Board
launched the Welsh
Homework Support Line.
This service provides help
with Welsh words or
terms, as well as practical
help with general matters
regarding homework.
Currently the service is
offered to Key Stage 2
pupils and their families.
The service is being
extended to the secondary
sector during 2007.
The preparatory work
incorporated a pilot in
eight Welsh-medium and
bilingual secondary
schools from September
2006 until March 2007.
This provided an
opportunity to ensure that
the appropriate structures
would be in place, prior to
launching the secondary
service nationally in April
2007.
The service operates from
3pm to 9pm, Sunday to
Friday. It can be contacted
by telephoning 0871 230
0029, or by emailing
post@gwaithcartref.com or
post@homeworkinwelsh.
com. A range of posters,
flyers and stickers promote
the service. For more
information, visit
www.bwrdd-yriaith.
org.uk.
Saesneg at home,
Cymraeg in school? –
the Twf Project
The trend in favour of
bilingualism provides
young people with great
advantages – but can also
create issues. How can
these parents support
their children with their
learning, especially
homework tasks?
Twf is an advisory
organisation, funded by
the National Assembly for
Wales, which promotes
bilingualism in the home,
and provides advice and
information on how these
issues can be addressed.
Clinics and one-to-one
meetings with the parents
of newly-enrolled school
children in such situations
are provided, including a
focus on early learning, a
guide to Welsh-language
books, and advice on
learning in and out of
school and at play.
The website is a useful
guide to this and other
aspects of the bilingual
home (www.twf
cymru.com); the leaflet
‘Homework’ is available
from Twf by telephoning
0871 230 0029. Further
advice at the local level
can be obtained from
Twf’s regional field officers.
A focus on the challenges
– Ysgol Moelwyn
homework club
Situated at the heart of
Blaenau Ffestiniog, the
school runs a support
system for pupils in Years
7 to 9 who have difficulties
managing homework,
resulting in failure to
complete, late submission,
or completion to a lower
standard than would be
expected.
An internal system of
referral through subject
teachers and year heads
initiates contact with
parents and, if the
situation persists, this
leads to an agreement
that the pupil attends the
homework club up to four
times per week, depending
on the situation.
The club is open to all
pupils, and ten per cent
of each of the three year
groups attends at least
once per week. The club
is staffed by a teacher on
three evenings per week,
and by a higher-level
teaching assistant for the
fourth.
This homework club is
not an isolated initiative,
but just one component of
a pattern of developments
in the school which have
made a huge difference to
pupils’ performance in
recent years.
Take your laptops home
– in Cerrigydrudion
Being well aware of the
problems of ‘fairness’ in
setting home-based tasks
for Years 5 and 6,
especially with regard to
the small number of pupils
who do not have access
to IT facilities at home,
Ysgol Uwchaled, a small
rural primary school in
Cerrigydrudion, Conwy,
has tackled the issue head
on by purchasing laptops
which identified pupils
are allowed to take home.
These computers can be
used for set tasks, but also
have software, such as
Word-Shark, for children
to develop their basic skills
bilingually.
This has been made
possible as part of a
community fund-aided
project, which also aims
to provide access to IT
facilities for high school
students and adults who
live in the village and are
also without these facilities
at home. The school
recognises that given the
high rate of PC ownership
these days, not many
children are involved,
but that as those without
become fewer, the
disadvantage to each
of those becomes
proportionally greater.
This mum likes the
homework club –
North Wales
This mum runs her own
small business, and her
husband currently works
overseas, so she has her
hands full with three
secondary school children.
The youngest had been
giving cause for concern –
not for any behavioural
reasons, but just a general
lack of interest in school,
aggravated by a mild
learning difficulty.
‘The school suggested he
might try the homework
club, twice a week. He
reluctantly decided to give
it a go – and it also fitted
conveniently with my own
hours. What a turn-round!
‘He found that he was not
the only one who didn’t
understand what was
needed, he had some
quality personal support,
and he quickly began to
produce better work in
some subjects, especially
maths and English.
‘Much more than that, he
has been encouraged to
read at the right level, and
he is now never without a
book – a few weeks ago
he wouldn’t be seen with
one! He is now making
demands on himself –
and on me! I wouldn’t
have believed that such a
simple idea could have
such a positive effect on
him. And he will not miss
the club for anything.’
Anonymous
(Note: This successful
facility is based in a school
with an extensive rural
9
catchment. The school is
concerned that this
restricts access to pupils
who live within a short
distance or whose parents
can provide transport – a
familiar scenario with all
out-of-school-hours
learning in such schools.
Thoughts are being
directed towards a strategy
to address this inequality
but in the meantime it is
thought better to continue
rather than not to provide
the club at all.)
Partnership and
decentralisation –
Ogmore Vale
In Bridgend, Ogmore
Vale High School is taking
several measures to
ensure that equality of
opportunity with
homework is a reality.
The headteacher, Nick
Oaten, believes that once
they are close to achieving
this then the school can
begin to implement their
vision of a fresh approach
to the whole concept of
homework, in which
research-based, ITC skillsbased
learning out-ofschool-
hours can become
the focus of a whole-school
‘Own Work’ approach.
For some time the
school has been running
a homework club one day
per week, based on staff
goodwill and with late
transport provided to
the communities up the
Ogmore valley. However,
the school is looking
beyond this and external
funding has been secured,
and being sought, for
a number of initiatives,
largely off-site and set in
the home communities
of the pupils.
The school has enjoyed
the full support of the LEA
out-of-school-hours
learning officer, who has
contributed much to the
community partnership
development and to
chasing the funding – and
key people within the
communities who have
initiated some aspects of
the developing homework
scene.
Primary schools, Bridgend
Association of Voluntary
Action, youth centre and
community centre staff,
the LEA and Communities
at One contribute to this
partnership with the
high school.
A facility is developing in
the youth centre in the
community of Blackmill,
a Communities First area,
with laptop, broadband
and wireless facilities. This
is staffed by a tutor with
ICT skills and a youth
worker as a project
assistant who will also link
to families and the school
as an outreach worker. In
the first instance, this will
be open one evening per
week for two hours, for
primary children and once
per week for secondary.
Ogmore Vale is not being
precious about access –
the club will be open to
children from other
schools who live in this
community, including
Welsh medium-educated
children.
Other community activities
for the children, and for
adult groups, are welcome
to dovetail into the scheme
after 6pm and to benefit
from the facilities.
Consultation with the
prospective pupil users has
taken place, and will be
ongoing, to assess the
demand and the type of
facility provided. In fact,
a key appointment is a
community consultant who
knocks on doors, canvasses
opinions and actually leads
the young people – and
older ones too – along to
the activities. A truly
personal approach!
A marketable perception is
seen as important and the
word ‘homework’ will not
appear in the name of any
of these activities.
It is hoped that, as well as
supporting children with
the completion of
standard homework tasks,
development of self-study/
IT skills will be addressed,
and additional activities
such as digital photography
could be included.
A similar pilot scheme is
being established in the
Ogmore Life Centre, and
eventually it is planned to
spread the concept
throughout the school
catchment by opening a
similar facility in Nantymoel.
Thinking further ahead,
the school is looking to the
future curriculum, which
will incorporate a more
skills-based approach, with
a corresponding need to
develop an approach to
homework which will sit
more comfortably with this
curriculum.
Cardiff’s learning centres
– the Caerau experience
This is just one of a
number of similar centres,
mostly high-school-based,
which Cardiff LEA has
developed and funds.
Glyn Derw High School in
Ely, Cardiff, hosts the
Caerau Learning Centre –
a school and community
facility which incorporates
a library and ITC suite
and is open for pupils at
breakfast and lunchtimes
and from 3pm to 5pm
after school. Additionally,
it is open on Saturday
mornings. As such, it
provides an ideal base for
tackling homework,
especially as it is situated in
one of the less privileged
parts of Wales.
The Caerau Centre has a
community function, and
is available to children
from local primary schools,
and from two nearby
special schools. A normal
attendance is 35 young
people at all sessions,
and is often more.
The successful operation of
the homework support
depends on good, paid
staff drawn from a rota of
teaching (especially IT)
staff, learning support
assistants, cover supervisors
and a cleaner who has now
become a trained learning
support assistant. A
community learning
development officer –
a former youth worker –
is also involved.
When setting homework,
the schools’ teachers are
aware of the potential of
the learning centre. They
set work accordingly and
encourage their pupils to
use the facility – not least
as it invalidates certain
pupil excuses!
A homework club with a
difference – Willows High
School, Cardiff
At Willows, the homework
club is also based in,
and funded through, the
learning centre, and has
received high praise from
Estyn in their recent
inspection, but more
importantly by the pupils –
with up to 100 attending
at any one time and never
less than 35.
What singles this club out
is that it does not run
straight after school. Being
in an inner-city location,
transport is not a problem
and early evening opening
for three nights per week –
5.30 to 7.30pm – has
proved to be very popular.
(There is a facility for pupils
to work straight through
after school if they wish.)
10
This gives the pupils a
chance to go home and
relax after the school day,
and to have something to
eat, before returning for
the club – and, as it is an
evening activity, uniform is
not required.
This does not mean that
the club is free and easy –
far from it, as there are
agreed requirements for
work and behaviour and a
purposeful and pleasant
learning ambience fostered
by the club leader and two
LSAs.
Pupils are expected to
work for at least one hour
on set homework. In some
subjects this might be
working on a term-long
assignment rather than
strictly timetabled shortterm
tasks.
If set homework does not
extend to an hour, the BBC
Bitesize revision website is
available, as is the Sam
Learning Programme*.
For some, other
constructive but less
demanding activities are
available for the second
hour, including quizzes,
something physical like
table tennis, or the
development of IT skills.
Although free to come and
go, most attendees stay for
the full two hours, and are
rewarded with a points
system – one per half-hour
– which can be ‘traded in‘
at the end of term for
something special, like an
activity weekend in an
outdoor centre.
Add in some peer
mentoring, with older or
more able pupils helping
others, and a tuck shop –
with toast and tea for
those who work through
from the end of school,
homework has become an
enjoyable collective
experience – invaluable for
those children who do not
enjoy the right conditions
at home.
This need is also met on
one other evening when
the club is available for
Year 11 examination work
only.
Further testament to the
popularity of the club is
that former pupils regularly
turn up to help – and
suspended and excluded
pupils, who are welcomed,
come along to keep up
with their work.
*The Sam Learning
Programme is available by
school subscription to a
private enterprise provider.
With something for all age
groups, it is based on an
individual log-in approach
for each pupil, and provides
a range of learning activities
with immediate feedback.
Schools can use this as a
basis for setting class
homework if all pupils have
access. For more
information, visit
www.SamLearning.com.
A genuine community
homework ‘provider’ –
Wrexham Homework
Clubs
Wrexham Homework
Clubs has its roots in a
local children’s charity,
The Venture, which began
its first homework club in
1993. The success of this
led to the establishment of
an independent charity
and the development of a
network of clubs across
the Borough.
With support from
numerous trusts and
organisations, most
recently from the Big
Lottery Fund and Children
in Need, seventeen clubs
are now running in
schools, community
centres and libraries, and
Wrexham is looking to
expand into communitybased
adult learning.
There are different types of
clubs:
• Extra (ten clubs): covers a
variety of oshl activities,
in conjunction with
schools.
• GCSE support (four
clubs): helps Year 10 and
11 students to maximise
their grades within the
core subjects, especially
for those students
• who are identified as
potentially benefiting
from extra help.
• Tackling the transition
issue – the Moving On
programme (three clubs):
operating in three
different locations
within the Borough, it is
beginning to incorporate
homework. It is aimed at
Year 5 and 6 pupils and
includes mentoring and
other activities with older
pupils.
• Established for only a few
months with Lloyd’s TSB
funding, the programme
is a mixture of modules
addressing children’s
fears and perceptions of
secondary school and
learning activities based
on the current curricular
topics in school.
• These learning activities
lean towards supportive
skills rather than
information, and are
devised in partnership
with the primary schools.
Wrexham Homework
Clubs is now aiming to
forge closer links with the
secondary schools to
develop the programme
further.
| Attachment | Size |
|---|---|
| making_homework_work-english.pdf | 2.31 MB |
| making_homework_work-welsh.pdf | 2.53 MB |


